CASE STUDY | Aerosol Analysis: Was There a Formulation Change?

Helping Clients Through Practical Analytical Solutions

Concern: Tile Sealant No Longer Safe?

A popular aerosol tile sealant had been a best seller for years. Consumers loved it – it worked well and had a good safety record. The manufacturer was puzzled when their product started being linked to illnesses – and even deaths. Facing litigation, they turned to MAS scientists to learn why a long-time safe product had become a potential health hazard.

MAS Solution: Make It Real

The most obvious answer was that a formulation change had been made to one of the components in the sealant, without the manufacturer’s knowledge. For MAS scientists to confirm this hypothesis and define exactly what had been changed, they needed to determine exposure during typical product use by analyzing both the air and surfaces. To simulate real world conditions, they constructed a shower stall inside MAS’s environmental characterization lab (ECL). The ECL allows containment of hazardous pollutants through a combination of negative pressurization and HEPA air filtration. Wearing proper protective gear, an MAS employee entered the chamber and sprayed the sealant – simulating actual consumer use of the product.

Test Process: Analyze the Collected Data

The employee wore an air sampling collection device, and there were several others in the ECL. MAS scientists gathered area and personal air samples, along with surface deposit samples, to determine the presence of volatile organic compounds (VOCs) and fluoropolymers during typical use. These products were analyzed by GC/MS to establish a component list. Air sample analysis by NIOSH method 1450/1500 consisted of desorption of the charcoal by carbon disulfide, followed by identification and quantification of aromatic hydrocarbons by GC/FID. For this test the cans were inverted and the product sprayed directly into a collection vial, then analyzed by GC/MS. Additionally, an analysis was performed to measure the residual dried components. A profile of each formulation was prepared, along with semi-quantitative results of each identified compound in the profile.

Results: Identifying the Unauthorized Formulation Change

MAS’s analysis confirmed that an unauthorized formulation change had been made by one of the manufacturer’s suppliers. But which component?


Earlier formulations of the sealant contained n-butyl acetate – a solvent with a pungent/acrid odor. Because of the overwhelming smell of the older formula, consumers would instinctively leave the area and limit their exposure.


In the new formula, the supplier substituted a sweet smelling, multi-component solvent. This seemingly inconsequential change turned out to be the root of the problem, as consumers would linger too long in the sprayed area and be overexposed to the fluoropolymer solvent. Based on MAS’s tests, the manufacturer was able to return to the safer, albeit less pleasant smelling, formulation.


MAS LABORATORY AND CONSULTING SERVICES


800-421-8451 • mastest.com

Resources

Teething Products' Potential Health Risks: How FDA Approved Laboratories Can Help

Understanding the Role of FDA Approved Laboratories

Understanding 16 CFR Part 1307: How MAS Ensures Compliance with Phthalate Regulations and Lead Testing

Certified Laboratory Solutions for Regulatory Compliance.

How ETL Identifies Manufacturing Defects in Children's Products

How Forensic Engineering and ETL help Identify Manufacturing Defects.

Forensic Engineering: The Growing Concern Over Microplastics in Children's Products

How Forensic Engineering Tackles Microplastics in Children's Products

Protecting Your Workforce: Industries at Risk of Asbestos Exposure and How MAS Ensures Asbestos Testing Compliance

Industries at Risk of Particles Exposure and How Asbestos Testing Can Help

Top Manufacturing Industries at Risk for Illegal Levels of Lead in Their Products and How to Test For Lead

Top Manufacturing Industries? Stay Compliant with MAS lead testing.

Ensuring Safety and Quality in Children's Products: A Guide for Manufacturers From a Certified Laboratory

Ensuring Safety and Quality in Children's Products: A Guide for Manufacturers From a Certified Laboratory

Baby Lounger Safety: A Manufacturer’s Guide to Product Safety Labs

Ensuring Baby Lounger Safety: A Manufacturer’s Guide to Product Standards

Modernizing Trace Metal Testing:

Ensuring Pharmaceutical Purity with Advanced Trace Metal Analysis

Understanding Bromopropane

Safeguarding Worker Health: New Insights into Bromopropane Exposure and Control Measures

Comprehensive Testing

Expert Surface and Particle Analysis, Polymer Microscopy, and Forensic Testing for Aerospace, Automotive, Medical Devices, and More

Discover the Future of Advanced

Revolutionizing Carbon and Polymer Materials Analysis for Semiconductors, Biotechnology, and Pharmaceuticals

Keeping Kids Safe: How MAS Tackles Water Bead Hazards in Toys

A new bipartisan bill, "Esther's Law," seeks to ban hazardous water beads in children's toys due to their severe risks when ingested. Materials Analytical Services (MAS) plays a crucial role in ensuring toy safety through rigorous testing and analysis. MAS helps identify potential hazards and ensure compliance with safety standards, preventing dangerous products from reaching the market. Learn how MAS contributes to safeguarding children's health and promoting a safer environment for play.

CASE STUDY | Material Analysis:

A leading L&G product manufacturer turned to MAS to evaluate consumer chemical exposure during handling. MAS conducted comprehensive tests on 16

CASE STUDY | Welding Exposure

A leading welding coatings manufacturer faced a product launch delay due to safety concerns. MAS conducted real-world evaluations and provided comprehensive

CASE STUDY | Aerosol Analysis:

A popular aerosol tile sealant linked to illnesses prompted the manufacturer to seek MAS's help. MAS identified an unauthorized formulation change by a

What Manufacturers Need to Know About the Recent Baby Swing Recall

The March 2024 recall of Jool Baby's Nova Baby Infant Swings underscores the critical need for rigorous safety testing of children's products. The recall was due to a suffocation hazard caused by an incline angle greater than 10 degrees. At Materials Analytical Services (MAS), we provide comprehensive testing and analysis to ensure product safety and compliance, helping manufacturers prevent hazards and costly recalls. Learn more about the importance of safety testing and how MAS supports manufacturers in producing safe children's products.

Are You an Online Manufacturer? Ensure Compliance Before Selling Your Baby Products Online

As a manufacturer of children's products, ensuring safety and compliance is crucial, especially in the growing consumer-to-manufacturer (C2M) market. With the direct connection to consumers online, it's essential to maintain high standards for safety and quality to meet both regulatory requirements and parental expectations.

Navigating New CPSC Regulations with MAS

In early 2024, the Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC) proposed significant updates to enhance product safety, including mandatory electronic filing of Certificates of Compliance for all imported CPSC-regulated products, broadening the definition of "importer" to include a wider range of stakeholders, and introducing detailed requirements for certificate content alongside a new five-year record retention period. Aimed at ensuring products entering the U.S. market meet safety standards, these changes emphasize accountability across the supply chain and enhance the CPSC's ability to monitor compliance. To navigate these complex regulations, Materials Analytical Services (MAS), a premier U.S.-based analytical and technical assistance laboratory, offers its expertise in product testing and compliance, providing essential support to companies aiming to meet these rigorous safety standards and protect consumer well-being.

FINAL SILICA EXPOSURE RULE

Crystalline silica, a natural substance found in various construction materials, poses significant health risks due to its respirability. To mitigate these risks, OSHA

Resources


Teething Products' Potential Health Risks: How FDA Approved Laboratories Can Help

Understanding the Role of FDA Approved Laboratories

Understanding 16 CFR Part 1307: How MAS Ensures Compliance with Phthalate Regulations and Lead Testing

Certified Laboratory Solutions for Regulatory Compliance.